Home
About Us
Welcome Video
Company Overview
Our Purpose
A Message from our CEO
Giving Back
Locations
Testimonials
Leadership
Executive Team
Legal Team
Careers
Contact
Phia Certification
Diversity & Inclusion
Privacy Statement
Technology
Services
Learn - Independent Consultation & Evaluation
Plan - Phia Document Management
Plan - Plan Drafting Services
Save - Claims, Recovery & Subrogation Services
Save - Claim Negotiation
Save - Phia Unwrapped
Protect - Plan Appointed Claim Evaluator (PACE)
Protect - Balance Billing Resolution
Phia International
Media
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Articles
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Employee Rights With COVID-19 Vaccines
The No Surprises Act Explained
Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Explained
Understanding Non-Quantitative Treatment Limitations (NQTLs)
The Insulin Cap Bill Offers Hope for Americans With Diabetes
Industry Terms
Members Area
FAQs
FAQ - Subrogation & Reimbursement
FAQ - Mass Tort Subrogation & Reimbursement
Questionnaire Response
Make A Payment
|
Login
GO
X
Home
About Us
Welcome Video
Company Overview
Our Purpose
A Message from our CEO
Giving Back
Locations
Testimonials
Leadership
Executive Team
Legal Team
Careers
Contact
Phia Certification
Diversity & Inclusion
Privacy Statement
Technology
Services
Learn - Independent Consultation & Evaluation
Plan - Phia Document Management
Plan - Plan Drafting Services
Save - Claims, Recovery & Subrogation Services
Save - Claim Negotiation
Save - Phia Unwrapped
Protect - Plan Appointed Claim Evaluator (PACE)
Protect - Balance Billing Resolution
Phia International
Media
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Articles
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Employee Rights With COVID-19 Vaccines
The No Surprises Act Explained
Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Explained
Understanding Non-Quantitative Treatment Limitations (NQTLs)
The Insulin Cap Bill Offers Hope for Americans With Diabetes
Industry Terms
Members Area
FAQs
FAQ - Subrogation & Reimbursement
FAQ - Mass Tort Subrogation & Reimbursement
Questionnaire Response
Make A Payment
Home
+
About Us
Welcome Video
+
Company Overview
Our Purpose
A Message from our CEO
Giving Back
Locations
Testimonials
+
Leadership
Executive Team
Legal Team
Careers
Contact
Phia Certification
Diversity & Inclusion
Privacy Statement
Technology
+
Services
Learn - Independent Consultation & Evaluation
Plan - Phia Document Management
Plan - Plan Drafting Services
Save - Claims, Recovery & Subrogation Services
Save - Claim Negotiation
Save - Phia Unwrapped
Protect - Plan Appointed Claim Evaluator (PACE)
Protect - Balance Billing Resolution
Phia International
-
Media
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
+
Industry Articles
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Employee Rights With COVID-19 Vaccines
The No Surprises Act Explained
Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Explained
Understanding Non-Quantitative Treatment Limitations (NQTLs)
The Insulin Cap Bill Offers Hope for Americans With Diabetes
Industry Terms
+
Members Area
+
FAQs
FAQ - Subrogation & Reimbursement
FAQ - Mass Tort Subrogation & Reimbursement
Questionnaire Response
Make A Payment
Posts
Media
>
Posts
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Articles
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Employee Rights With COVID-19 Vaccines
The No Surprises Act Explained
Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Explained
Understanding Non-Quantitative Treatment Limitations (NQTLs)
The Insulin Cap Bill Offers Hope for Americans With Diabetes
Industry Terms
Phia Group
Phia Group Media
Bidding Against Themselves: $750K Air Ambulance Claim Adventure
On March 29, 2017 in
Balance Billing
,
Blog
,
Cost Containment
,
Health Insurance
,
Healthcare Costs
I have a weird claim on my desk right now involving an Air Ambulance (AA) carrier that is billing a client $750K for a flight from the east coast to the west coast.
It is not uncommon for an AA carrier to argue that their charges are reasonable and even show us some so-called usual, customary, reasonable (UCR) charge data to justify their charges. We find ourselves commonly reminding them that their calculation of UCR is not relevant to the Plan’s payment – but rather the reimbursement will be based on the terms of the Plan Document. We also counter with data of our own (because we want do want to be fair), and we end up settling at a rate that everyone can live with.
…usually
In the case I mentioned above, the AA carrier is sticking to their UCR plastic guns, and they are presenting a 10% discount proudly, as if the employer should be thankful. To be clear, the AA carrier has a UCR database that is showing their charges are “normal.” $750K! UC-R you kidding me?
If it were up to me, we would send them a check and tell them where to stick their 10% discount, but our client, as is common, would like an agreement on the claim to protect the member from harassment. This is a classic ransom scenario; the balance-billing and credit-ruining boogieman is meant to scare the employer into paying more than a reasonable amount for this flight. Regardless, our directives are to use our legal and claim data expertise to “persuade” the AA carrier to accept a lower reasonable price.
In this case, to do this, we secured two quotes from other competitive AA carriers for the same flight (distance, resources, etc.) and the quotes came in at $35K and $50K. Yes, you read that right – basically $700K less than these billed charges. For good measure, we also consulted another UCR publisher, which quoted UCR at $47K – right in line with the quotes received. Now, we understand that pre-service quotes are less than post-service charges, but certainly this is enough data to get them “in range.”
…uh…no
We presented these market-based quotes and other UCR data to the AA carrier as a benchmark of “fair market value.” They scoffed, refusing to budge, and they are now saying they want to take this to court because of their “ironclad” UCR data.
Here’s the best part. We managed to secure a quote from the very same AA carrier that billed $750K (everything is the same). The SAME carrier. The SAME flight. They offered in writing, $35K (insert nausea).
Believe it or not, we are still trying to get this matter resolved. Moral of the story? Don’t let anyone else (despite their best intentions) exclusively define and calculate UCR for you, because they may get it wrong, as this case clearly shows. Instead, make sure your plan documents have a comprehensive definition that is fair to the provider, the member, and the Plan based on objective, real-world, fair market measures. At best, an unreasonable UCR calculation shocks the conscience; at worst, it can obliterate your wallet.
Tagged With:
Air Ambulance