Home
+
About Us
Welcome Video
Company Overview
Our Purpose
A Message from our CEO
Testimonials
+
Leadership
Executive Team
Legal Team
Careers
Giving Back
Locations
Contact
Phia Certification
Diversity & Inclusion
Privacy Statement
Covid-19 Resources
+
Services
Learn - Independent Consultation & Evaluation
Plan - Phia Document Management
Plan - Plan Drafting Services
Save - Claims, Recovery & Subrogation Services
Save - Claim Negotiation
Save - Phia Unwrapped
Protect - Plan Appointed Claim Evaluator (PACE)
Protect - Patient Defender & Balance Billing
Phia International
-
Media
Covid-19
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Terms
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
+
Members Area
Frequently Asked Questions
Questionnaire Response
Make A Payment
888-986-0080
info@phiagroup.com
Questionnaire Response
Blog
|
Login
Home
About Us
Welcome Video
Company Overview
Our Purpose
A Message from our CEO
Testimonials
Leadership
Executive Team
Legal Team
Careers
Giving Back
Locations
Contact
Phia Certification
Diversity & Inclusion
Privacy Statement
Covid-19 Resources
Services
Learn - Independent Consultation & Evaluation
Plan - Phia Document Management
Plan - Plan Drafting Services
Save - Claims, Recovery & Subrogation Services
Save - Claim Negotiation
Save - Phia Unwrapped
Protect - Plan Appointed Claim Evaluator (PACE)
Protect - Patient Defender & Balance Billing
Phia International
Media
Covid-19
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Terms
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Members Area
Frequently Asked Questions
Questionnaire Response
Make A Payment
Posts
Media
>
Posts
Covid-19
Webinars
Newsletters
Publications
Blog
Press Releases
Podcasts
Industry Terms
Guide to Understanding Subrogation
Moving To Self-Funded Health Plan Guide
Referenced-Based Pricing Explained
Hospital Price Transparency Guide
Balance-Billing: What Patients Need To Know
Phia Group Media
Phia Group Media
A Win for the Good Guys!
On June 7, 2017 in
Blog
,
ERISA
,
Fifth Circuit
By: Chris Aguiar, Esq.
Subrogation added another case to the win column last week when the 5th Circuit ruled in favor of a benefit plan’s reimbursement rights even though the Plan only had an SPD, and that SPD referenced another, nonexistent document. I know what you are thinking … “Wait a minute, Chris, most of my clients only have an SPD, so why should I care about this?” The answer is because in 2011, the Supreme Court gave us a decision in Cigna v. Amara that muddied the waters on whether an SPD alone can be the governing document for an ERISA health benefit plan. In short, the late Justice Antonin Scalia indicated that it couldn’t be, but that case was about pension benefits that were being altered and it included a plan that did in fact have two documents. The truth is ERISA requires “a written instrument”; nowhere in the statute is that requirement defined to mean that multiple documents are required, but that didn’t stop Justice Scalia from writing in his opinion that a summary by definition implies that a more comprehensive document is available. Many attorneys attempt to use that decision to argue that if a plan doesn’t have a “plan document” and only an SPD, it cannot enforce its rights. In some areas of the country, where a plan’s subrogation rights are always under attack (e.g. the 9th Circuit), decisions like this cause problems. Anytime the Supreme Court makes statements that may be subject to interpretation, a plan’s rights can be called into question until a court in that plan’s jurisdiction (or the Supreme Court itself) provides clarification. The 5th Circuit gave us that clarification with this decision and it gives us another tool to fight the argument we contend with every day.
Tagged With:
,
ERISA